Although slight variations may exist in regional guidelines
of projects, the national standards are widely used. Student
researchers must categorize their research in one of the
six research areas: Environmental Science (Earth and Space
Science), Engineering, Physical Sciences, Life Sciences,
Medicine and Health (Behavioral and Social Sciences), and
Mathematics and Computer Science. Students begin by submitting
a 200-word abstract, containing the researcher's project
title, name, high school (city and state), and designated
teacher/sponsor/mentor. The research should engage the interest
and curiosity of readers from many backgrounds while presenting
the nature of the research problem, brief methodology, and
significant conclusions reached.
Students are then required to electronically submit a written
paper of the research conducted. The paper should be at
least 5-6 pages, but no more than 20, appendices included.
The maximum file size allotted for submission is 1.8 megabytes.
The paper should contain a title page, acknowledgements,
table of contents, introduction, materials and methodology,
results, discussion/conclusions, references, and any appendices.
Any graphs, tables, and figures should be easily viewable
by the judges.
Finally, students prepare an oral presentation for delivery
at the symposium. 12 minutes are allotted for each presentation,
followed by a 6-minute question-and-answer session primarily
by the judges. Audio-visual equipment provided by the symposium
includes an overhead projector, LCD projector, projection
screen, a laser pointer, and a PC-based computer configured
with Microsoft 2000 PowerPoint and Adobe Acrobat. Further
details are provided on the National JSHS website.
Students' oral presentations are judged on a 100-point
scale, as enumerated by the judges' scoring sheet, which
can be accessed at the JSHS website. Scoring is based on
the statement and identification of a research problem;
acknowledgement of sources and major assistance received;
creativity and originality; research or engineering design,
procedure, and results; discussion/conclusions; and skill
in communicating the results (both orally and in writing).
Judges are those who are actively involved in research or
hold a doctorate degree, and may or may not be specialized
in the student's chosen field of work. It is highly recommended
that students follow the judging sheet when constructing
their presentations, as points are awarded on the basis
of a "checklist," following each of the presented
criteria. Presentation of graphical displays should be kept
simple yet sufficient to convey the underlying message.
Students should also be prepared to communicate their findings
in an eloquent manner easily understandable by a variety
of judges and audience members.